Bankruptcy vs Debt Settlement. Which is Better?

Bankruptcy vs Debt Settlement. Which is Better?

Which describes your current financial situation?

  • You are struggling with payments on your bills and credit cards
  • You are drowning in debt and facing threats of legal actions from creditors

When facing extreme financial hardship and significant debt, you need a solution that can help you get out of debt. But should you just file bankruptcy to wipe out your debts or try a debt settlement? How can a Licensed Insolvency Trustee help you make a settlement offer to your creditors?

Considering debt settlement or bankruptcy

Both bankruptcy and debt settlement are options for people who can’t get out of debt by budgeting, can’t get a debt consolidation loan, and don’t qualify for a debt management plan. In other words, consumers who cannot afford to repay their debts in full. In this case you are left with two common debt relief options – declaring personal bankruptcy or debt settlement. Below I’ll help you learn about the pros and cons of each and how to know you are dealing with a trusted professional.

Bankruptcy Pros and Cons

Bankruptcy in Canada is a legal process that is governed by federal law. Bankruptcy erases debt in exchange for the surrender of certain assets and regulated bankruptcy payments.

There are several advantages to bankruptcy over other debt relief solutions.

  • Bankruptcy is generally the fastest way out of debt. A first time bankrupt with no surplus income can be discharged in 9 months.
  • If you face threats of legal action from your creditors, such as a lawsuit or wage garnishment, bankruptcy provides a stay of proceedings that stops these actions.
  • Since it deals with unsecured debt, bankruptcy can eliminate credit card debt, bank loans, payday loans, student loans over 7 years, and taxes owing to the Canada Revenue Agency.
  • Because it is governed by the Bankruptcy & Insolvency Act, the bankruptcy process is safe and relatively predictable.

On the downside, bankruptcy can become expensive if your income exceeds the government-set surplus income threshold. The base cost to file bankruptcy in Canada is around $1,800. However, bankruptcy law says you must pay one-half of every dollar you earn above the surplus income threshold into your bankruptcy estate to benefit your creditors.

If you declare bankruptcy, you also risk losing assets like your home equity or RESP unless you can pay the trustee an equivalent cash value.

Debt Settlement Pros and Cons

Debt settlement is an arrangement to repay your creditors less than you owe. It’s a way to deal with accounts in collection and debts with high interest rates. Depending on your budget, you make a lump sum settlement or payments over a period of three to five years.

To enter a debt settlement plan, you need to find a company that will negotiate with your creditors and come up with a repayment plan. In Canada, that may mean talking with a debt consultant or Licensed Insolvency Trustee. The settlement options provided by these different debt advisors are not the same.

  • A big debt settlement company provides informal debt settlement negotiation services.
  • A Licensed Insolvency Trustee can settle your debts through a federally regulated program called a consumer proposal.

Let’s start with a discussion of how debt settlement works with large for-profit debt settlement companies.

Once you are enrolled in a debt settlement program, you start making monthly payments to the company you are using. The company uses this money to cover their fees for using its services as well as the cost of the settlement. Because of past abuses by debt settlement companies charging very high prices, many provinces have prohibited upfront charges and limited overall fees. In Ontario, the maximum allowable fee for debt settlement is 15% of payments.

Over the past few years, consumers have become increasingly aware of the dangers of debt settlement through a for-profit debt settlement company.

  • Informal debt settlement can significantly harm your credit. Debt settlement companies frequently advise that you withhold payments while they negotiate a better deal. The problem is, creditors will report these as late payments on your credit report, lowering your credit score.
  • You can end up in even more debt. Suppose your creditor refuses to settle your debt, and you stop your payments during the negotiating period? In that case, you could find yourself owing more than you started with due to interest and late payment penalties.
  • Creditors can still pursue collections. Debt settlement agencies cannot offer protection from creditor actions. If you stop making your minimum payments, most creditors will take action to collect on your debt long before the agency can get in touch with your creditor. If your account is sent to collections, this is one more bad mark on your credit rating.
  • The success rate is low. The participation of individual creditors is voluntary. Most larger creditors have policies against dealing with these companies.
  • Not all debts can be included. Debt settlement companies cannot deal with government debts like student loans and taxes, and most payday lenders will not work with them either.

So, if settling your debts through a large company is risky, and there is no guarantee of success, is there a safer debt settlement option? Can you settle debt through a bankruptcy proceeding?

Consumer Proposal Settlement Benefits

The term debt settlement is used for two types of settlement services in Canada: entering into an informal debt settlement agreement and settling debts through a consumer proposal. Consumer proposals provide debt relief to Canadians who want to avoid bankruptcy.

If you want to use a debt settlement program sanctioned by the Canadian government, you should consider a consumer proposal.

A consumer proposal avoids many of the disadvantages and pitfalls of informal debt settlement. Specifically, a consumer proposal:

  • is a legally binding debt settlement agreement you file with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee,
  • provides the full creditor protection of the Bankruptcy & Insolvency Act,
  • sets payment terms based on what you can afford and what the creditors expect to receive,
  • deals with unsecured debt including credit cards, lines of credit, student debt and can even settle tax debt,
  • allows you to keep any assets that would be forfeited in bankruptcy.

A consumer proposal is a debt relief and debt consolidation program that allows you to make one lower monthly payment and deal with all your problem debt.

The settlement you can get through a consumer proposal depends on your income, assets you own, and total debt. Proposal payments can be spread out over a maximum of five years, without interest. In many cases, this can result in savings of up to 70%.

A consumer proposal is also often cheaper than working with a for-profit debt settlement company. If your creditors are willing to accept 35 cents on the dollar, that is all you pay in a proposal. Your trustee fees are included in the settlement amount. In contrast, a debt settlement company may be able to negotiate the same 35 cent offer, but they will then add their 15% fee on top.

So why would creditors settle your debts for less than you owe? Because they know the alternative is for you to file personal bankruptcy. When working with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee, creditors know this risk is credible, which is why trustees have a better success rate than debt consultants.

While not all debt settlement companies are successful when talking with creditors, consumer proposals have a much higher success rate. At Hoyes, Michalos 99% of proposals filed are accepted by the creditors. Also, creditors have 45 days to accept your proposal, shortening the window of uncertainty. It is not uncommon to wait six months or more to finalize a deal through a debt consultant during which you are ignoring payments and watching your credit score disintegrate.

Which option is better, or worse, for your credit score?

Any form of debt restructuring program will affect your credit score.

Filing bankruptcy will cause your credit rating to fall immediately, but this is only temporary. The information about your bankruptcy will remain on your credit report for up to seven years for a first bankruptcy and 14 years for a second one. A consumer proposal remains on your credit for a maximum period of 6 years from the date it was filed.

This doesn’t mean that you can’t get any credit when you file a bankruptcy or proposal. People who take active steps to repair their credit after filing insolvency can get regular credit cards, car loans and, over time, a mortgage. Most can qualify for a mortgage two to three years after re-establishing new credit lines, dependant on other qualifying criteria like your income.

A debt settlement will impact your credit for at least six years, but possibly longer. Informal debt settlement can severely harm your credit if the process does not go smoothly. While you are in the negotiating stage, your credit score will drop, especially if you stop making payments.

Suppose your debt settlement company takes six months to negotiate but cannot make an agreement (or you can afford to maintain the agreed-upon payments). In that case, you will have several new negative marks on your credit history and higher debt, making it difficult to recover.

Because there is no stay of proceedings, some creditors might continue to report accounts as making payments or in collection. Individual debts will not be removed until seven years from the date of the last activity. If that is the date of your final payment, that means debts settled through a debt settlement program can remain on your report much longer than a bankruptcy or consumer proposal.

Bankruptcy and debt settlement calculators

So how can you calculate whether bankruptcy or debt settlement is right for your situation? How do you determine if your income is too high to make bankruptcy a good idea but high enough to afford a settlement offer through a consumer proposal?

Begin with our surplus income and bankruptcy calculator. Calculate what your monthly surplus income payments might be if you were to declare bankruptcy based on your income and family size. Keep in mind: if you have assets that must be seized and sold in a bankruptcy, this will increase your bankruptcy cost as well. Always speak with a trustee for guidance on your actual costs.

If you determine you have potentially high surplus income, move on to our consumer proposal calculator.  This will provide an estimate of the minimum creditors might accept in a debt settlement compared to other debt restructuring programs like debt consolidation or credit counselling. Again, each situation is unique. If you have significant assets, like high home equity, this will increase the amount you will need to offer your creditors to get them to accept the deal. A good read is our reference article on calculating consumer proposal payments.

Making the final decision

In summary, bankruptcy erases debt in exchange for the surrender of assets and regulated payments while debt settlement is an arrangement to repay less than you owe.

If you can’t afford to pay your debt in full, consider talking to a Licensed Insolvency Trustee about your debt relief options.

A consumer proposal is filed with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. As a federally licensed and trained debt expert, a Licensed Insolvency Trustee is a good alternative to working with a debt settlement company.

They can help you compare bankruptcy vs debt settlement vs a consumer proposal. Contact us today for a free, no-obligation consultation.

Similar Posts:

  1. Can a Medical Doctor in Canada File for Bankruptcy and Still Practice Medicine?
  2. Who Can File a Consumer Proposal?
  3. Debt Settlement: Which Option Lets You Rebuild Your Credit Faster?
  4. 25 Things You Must Know About a Consumer Proposal
  5. Bankruptcy Options in Canada

Get A Personalized Debt Free Plan

Contact A Trustee ›
Debt Free in 30 Podcast with Doug Hoyes

Find an Office Near You

Offices throughout Toronto and Ontario

google logoHoyes, Michalos & Associates Inc.Hoyes, Michalos & Associates Inc.
4.9 Stars - Based on 1077 User Reviews
facebook logoHoyes, Michalos & Associates Inc.Hoyes, Michalos & Associates Inc.
4.8 Stars - Based on 46 User Reviews

SignUp For Our Newsletter

Please enter valid email.

Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest articles, financial tips, giveaways and advice delivered right to your inbox. Privacy Policy